In yesterday’s post, I dealt with Part 1 of the reaction to Facebook COO Sheryl Sandberg’s book, Lean In, Women, Work and the Will to Lead, which was the reaction of other women. Today I want to discuss the missing piece of this ongoing conversation about how women get ahead in the business world, which is the reaction of the men.
What reaction? What men? Oh, right, virtually all the intelligent and impassioned responses to the book and to @SherylSandberg’s many interviews have come from women. Except for Dan Zevin’s snarky parody in the New York Times (@nytimes), Lean In, Buddy Boy, the men have been mostly silent.
Well, why not? What do they have to gain from jumping into this discussion? Absolutely nothing. And men have learned to lean back from this particular red-hot poker unless forced to do otherwise. I think there’s another reason as well. As Lily Tomlin used to say in her role as Ernestine, the telephone operator, “We don’t care. We don’t have to. We’re the phone company.” Men don’t care about this particular issue because they don’t have to. They’re in charge—and we’re doing all the work of figuring it out for them.
In Monday’s interview with @Soledad_OBrien on CNN’s Starting Point, Ms. Sandberg mentions the role of men, but it’s in general terms of what men need to be doing to change things. Here’s the thing, though: men don’t have a business reason to be doing anything.
As Ms Sandberg says, men run the business world. They are the wizards behind the curtain—and in front of it, too, no matter what they might say. That’s no surprise to any woman who has ever worked in America, although it seems to be something of a shock to young women just starting out. The secret of why men are the missing piece in this conversation lies in how boys and girls are socialized.
According to Pat Heim, Ph.D., in her excellent book called Hardball for Women, boys are socialized to be competitive, to be a good team player and obey the coach, to be aggressive or to at least “posture” aggressiveness, to be a leader who stays focused on the goal, to take criticism and praise, and to have a game plan because winning is all that matters. If you compare that with yesterday’s description of how girls are socialized, you will see that (A) they are very different, and (B) there is little in the female way of doing things that boys would admire, want to imitate, or find valuable for oh, so many reasons.
Looking Up, Not Down
There are, of course, jokes and comedy routines about the differences. Husbands might read about Mars and Venus but, if they actually apply that knowledge, it’s only to the home and not to the business world. Business is a man’s world; always was and, they probably think, should always be. Why change? After all, what can women add that will help a man be more successful?
So women continue to struggle. In yesterday’s interview, Ms. Sandberg gives reasons why men would want to lean in themselves, and seek to advance women in the workplace. “It should be a badge of honor to mentor a young woman,” she says. Later, she comments that it’s too hard for men to talk about gender. “We have to let men talk about this.” Also, “I hope men enter the conversation and the controversy around my book, because — and every issue, not just mine, every issue –. because we need men to talk about this, too, if it’s ever going to change.” Well, “should” and “hope” are not words that work in the corporate environment. Try putting them in your business plan and see how well it goes over in the executive suite.
The Missing Piece
We certainly do need men to talk about this—they are the missing piece—but it’s not up to us women to allow those sensitive souls to do that. Men have to want to do that. Nicole Pollizzi gets tougher with men in her article on @PolicyMic.com: Sheryl Sandberg’s Lean In: Men Must Lean In Too. She notes, accurately, that the problem is not the lack of women working to change things. Then Polizzi opines that the reason is that men devalue women’s work. While that’s certainly true of housework and childcare, I don’t agree that it’s a valid reason in the business world. The work that needs doing inside organizations has value in men’s eyes; it’s women and the style in which we work who don’t.
Men have to lean in themselves and make an effort. As Ms.Pollizzi asks, “So, at the risk of sounding supremely lazy, my question is, after ‘leaning in’ all the way for the last century or so, when should we expect our male counterparts, and bosses, to lean in and meet us halfway?” Even in this totally reasonable statement, she has to qualify her question so she doesn’t sound “supremely lazy.” What is lazy about asking men to do something?
Three Things That Drive Change
When, indeed? What does it take to get men get past their socialization to see that women bring strengths to business that go far beyond work/life balance? What does it take for men to understand that women are smart and resourceful, add a valuable perspective, have a great work ethic, can multi-task efficiently, work well on teams, and are as dedicated to their jobs as men are? Here are a few possible drivers of change:
- Generational: Gender equality has made a lot of progress in the last 40 years. Young men don’t think in the same rigid patterns as older men do. Maybe we just need more creative thinkers like Mark Zuckerberg and fewer old white guys to open the doors to the executive suite.
- Educational: Right now, in the 21st Century, more women graduate from college, than men do. While the number of women in college has been rising since the 1950s, total enrollment figures show that females outnumbered their male counterparts for the first time in the late 1970s, and they have steadily increased their numerical advantage ever since. That means the pool of educated and qualified men is dropping, while the number of educated and qualified women is growing. Will that push men to promote more women or will executives just try to bring in more men from overseas?
- Entrepreneurial: Women may have to start their own companies and hire other women to break the mold and create a new paradigm. Social media is making is possible to raise money outside the traditional structure of venture and equity capital firms, through crowd funding and angel investors. As reader Maura Schreier-Fleming of Dallas says in a letter to today’s Wall Street Journal (@wallstreetj4u), “Talented women are going to make the choice where they want to be and they can ably construct their careers to accommodate both family and work. It just might not be in corporate America.”