Why SNL’s Sister Sketch Is Going Viral

When I first saw the Sister video, a Saturday Night Live fake infomercial, I was blown away. It lays out exactly what happens in families as parents age and require care. Because the United States doesn’t have a national care program for the elderly, those duties and responsibilities fall on family members.

Well, not all family members.

The fake informercial sketch starts with host John Mulaney telling the audience:

“My dad means the world to me, so when I noticed him start to slow down, I knew I needed to get him the best care possible. I didn’t want to put him in a nursing home, but a private health aide could cost thousands a week. I didn’t know where to turn; that’s when I heard about Sister.”

In the video, which is told from the son’s point of view, the best thing to do is activate Sister mode. “Sister is a live-in, 24×7 eldercare provider that is completely free and also your sister.”

Sister, sketch, SNL, Saturday Night LiveA Biting Satire on Eldercare

The sketch is intended as comedy –and it is funny—but it’s one of those satires that bites a little closer to the bone than is comfortable. Sister mode means dumping all that work on your sister so you, the man, can go about your normal, happy life unencumbered by responsibility. Also by guilt.

What happens if you don’t have a sister? The video doesn’t deal with this scenario but, typically, it’s the son’s responsibility to get married so his wife, the daughter in law, will do all the work. Then you, the man, can continue your life as usual.

What doesn’t happen, except in rare circumstances, is the son taking responsibility for his parents. Instead, the sketch shows him on a jet ski having a good time while Sis deep cleans the house.

Many people have Liked and Shared the link to this SNL sketch. As of this writing, it has been viewed on YouTube 5,240,963 times. Melinda French Gates weighed in on Facebook:

“I don’t know of any Saturday Night Live sketch that has so quickly made its way into so many group chats as the commercial this week where John Mulaney touts an ingenious solution to caring for an aging relative without disrupting his own life: his sister.

The sketch is funny because it’s a little too true. Just how true? We checked—with help from research by Pivotal partners who have been documenting these realities for years. Behind just about every joke in the sketch is a tough fact about women and caregiving.

I’m so glad we’re talking about this, and laughing about it. We need more honesty about what caring for loved ones really takes and why so much of that work falls to women.

But I’d love for the day to come when these jokes don’t pack quite the same punch—because we’ve made it so much easier to care for the people we love.”

We would all love for that day to come but it won’t happen if we just wait around for things to change. That’s not the way life works.

When I Was Activated

Sister, Sketch, SNL, Saturday Night Live, eldercareI have watched the Sister sketch several times. It resonates with me because I as the youngest child and youngest daughter got activated when my parents started slipping.

In many cultures, this is expected, the way things are done and accepted by everyone. The youngest daughter (not the eldest) doesn’t marry so she can stay home and become the live-in, 24×7 eldercare provider.

What that does to her life is not relevant. It’s expected that she will pay her parents back for giving her life. Her siblings bear no such responsibility. Their job is to give grandchildren.

Sister Juggles All the Work

I know how it feels to be Sister because I’ve been there and done that. I even wrote about in a blog post called “Parental Care: Crossing the Invisible Line” several years ago. Susanne also wrote about it when she was caring for her father, which she did much longer than I and from further away.

Sister, SNL, Saturday Night Live, eldercareBut things were different for me. I did marry and had children of my own, so I got to juggle a demanding full-time job, taking care of my nuclear family, and doing what I could for my parents from 75 miles away. I couldn’t even think about quitting my job and moving closer if I had wanted to. Which I didn’t.

Where were my siblings? One brother lives in Louisiana and the other in Maryland, so they weren’t close enough to drop by and check on our parental units. My older sister lives in Massachusetts and much closer to my parents than I. But she “preferred not to get involved.” Sister mode doesn’t apply just to the boys in the family.

It bothers the son in the video not at all that his sister will “quit her job, break her lease and move halfway across the country” to become that caretaker. He lives a lot closer and could do more, but prefers not to.

The painful truth is that the man-baby would happily let his sister make all the sacrifices, do all the work, and handle all the arrangements so he doesn’t have to. Why? Because he doesn’t want to grow up and accept adult responsibilities.

This is what young people call adulting and he’s failing at it. From what I see posted online by young women, many men are doing exactly that.

Sister Mode: Been There, Done That

A menopause doctor posted on Facebook with a list of the physical problems female caretakers demonstrate after becoming caretakers. These include: “higher blood pressure, accelerated visceral fat, missed medical appointments, and higher rates of anxiety and depression (especially when caring for a parent with dementia).” I’m sure I developed some of those but the worst, most painful one also broke the cycle.

In the middle of a  hectic month where we were taking our daughter to visit college campuses, work was intense, and the cat ate my son’s hamster, I tried to get in a session at the gym before making the long Sunday drive to my parents’ home. I misjudged one step on the basement stairs and broke my ankle in multiple places. Did stress contribute to my accident? You betcha.

Five hours of surgery later, I was in a hospital room with my leg in traction and no chance of going anywhere for a while. At that point, my husband got on the phone and informed my siblings that Sister mode was malfunctioning and they would have to compensate.

One brother jumped in and persuaded my sister to change her mind. They pitched in. I was on crutches for eight weeks. And just like that, I was off the hook. As a solution to the eldercare problem, however, I do not recommend it.

Sister Mode Off the Hook

It could be worse. I have witnessed the consequences of Sister mode becoming toxic. Imagine being the caretaker with no chance of getting a job, nowhere to escape, no acceptable reason for abandoning your family responsibility and no help from your siblings. That means no way out. For years.

Think about that.

The Benefits of Remaining Single

I was really glad to see this sketch, which was written by three men. Lately I have seen a lot of women talking online about the benefits of remaining single. A big reason is immature men like the son in this sketch, happy to unload both work and responsibility on the nearest woman.

Unfortunately, being single makes you much more vulnerable to Sister mode. My solution is to consider this when you are voting. As I said, the world doesn’t change unless you make it do so.

The irony for me is that I am now the age my parents were back then. And I find eldercare more personal because I’m the one who may need it in the not-too-distant future. We have a son and a daughter.

Related Posts