Washington Street Before George Washington

Capt. John Bonner, Map of Boston, Washington Street

Capt. John Bonner Map of Boston (1722)

You can find a Washington Street in in many cities and towns across America. What patriotic citizens wouldn’t name a street after our country’s Founding Father? Boston has a Washington Street, of course. How could we not?

But think about it. Boston was founded in 1630, over a hundred years before George Washington was born. So, what was that street called before it took on the name of our first President? To begin with, it wasn’t one long street. Washington Street also changed its names and its course over the years.

All the Way to New York City

Today’s Washington Street begins in Keany Square at the south end of the Charlestown Bridge, where Causeway Street and Commercial Street intersect. We now call this section North Washington Street. It ends at Haymarket Square near what is now Government Center, but it was previously truncated by the no-longer-extant Scollay Square.

Washington Street, Downtown Crossing, Jordan Marsh, Filene's, Old South Meeting House

Washington Street at Downtown Crossing

Washington Street picks up again where Court Street becomes State Street and runs through Downtown Crossing. These blocks once held Boston’s two big department stores, Filene’s and Jordan Marsh, as well as the Jewelry Exchange Building. While the stores have changed over time, Washington Street still has a heavy commercial presence.

From there, it moves through the South End across what used to be Boston Neck, the narrow isthmus that connected the Shawmut Peninsula to the mainland. In fact, Washington Street provided the only road going across the neck to Roxbury.

Outside of Boston, Washington Street continues south, through multiple small towns and all the way to the Rhode Island border. Both then and now, it was an important thoroughfare—the Boston Post Road to New York City.

Washington Street’s Many Names

No one names a street after someone who won’t show up on the scene for a century, so let’s look at what it used to be called. We will start at Water Street and go through four names as we move west:

  • Cornhill (Not Road or Street or Way. Saying Cornhill Street means you’re not from around here.): Laid out in 1708 and named for London’s Cornhill, it went up from Water Street to Dock Square as part of a winding road between Roxbury and Boston. In 1816 Cornhill extended to the Old South Meeting House on School Street.
  • Marlborough Street went from the short distance (about three blocks) from School Street south to the intersection with Summer Street on the south and Winter Street on the north.
  • Newbury Street ran another few blocks from the Summer Street/Winter Street corner south to Essex Street/Boylston Street.
  • Orange Street from Essex Street/Boylston Street south to the fortification located near what is now East Berkeley Street (then Dover Street). Early maps, including Capt. John Bonner’s map of 1722, mark the road across Boston Neck as Orange Street.

You can see that it must have been confusing as you traveled along a street that changed its name from one block to another.

From Many Streets, One

Charles Bulfinch, Triumphal Arch, Boston, George Washington

Bulfinch’s Triumphal Arch

I would like to say that this all changed in 1789 when President George Washington came to town. But that did not happen. Touring the three New England states that had ratified the new Constitution, the first POTUS was met in Boston with a hero’s welcome.

Charles Bulfinch designed a triumphal arch for a parade to pass through — his first public architectural commission. City fathers renamed several streets.

It would have been a grand gesture to rename all four streets in George Washington’s name with one stroke of a quill pen. Boston tends to do things in a more piecemeal fashion, however, a pattern that continues in today’s Seaport District.

Old to New Cornhill

President Washington did drive over “Old Cornhill” during his visit and that portion was renamed as Washington Street in his honor. Old Cornhill returned to life as New Cornhill in 1816 when entrepreneur and developer Uriah Cotting plotted its path from Adams Square to Court Street. Even then, the name changed over time from Cheapside to Market Street and eventually to Cornhill.

Sears Crescent, Cornhill, Government Center, Boston

Sears Crescent on Cornhill

New Cornhill curved in a graceful way and attracted booksellers and publishers. By the mid-nineteenth century, it had become the heartbeat of Boston’s intellectual community, drawing religious, social, and political thinkers.

The Brattle Book Shop began there as Burnham’s bookstore, William Lloyd Garrison published “The Liberator” and the first edition of “Uncle Tom’s Cabin” came off the presses on Cornhill. Authors included transcendentalists, philosophers and abolitionists.

This section, along with the booksellers, fell to the wrecker’s ball when Government Center was created in the 1960s. Only the Sears Crescent building and the Sears Block remain to mark its curve along the south side of windswept City Hall Plaza.

Down with King and Queen Streets

Royalty lost favor during the Revolutionary War. King Street became State Street and Court Street replaced Queen Street. Orange Street had already been renamed Washington Street on July 4 of 1788, before President Washington’s visit. The section around Dudley Square north of Roxbury received its name on May 9, 1825. The new name extended north to Adams Square on July 6, 1825.Finally, it was applied to a new road to Haymarket Square on November 6 of 1872.

Today you can trace the path of the Old Cornhill by walking 144 feet along City Hall Plaza in front of the Sears Crescent (1816). Arthur D. Gilman recycled the Marlborough and Newbury Street names when he laid out the Back Bay grid in 1857. Orange Street appears lost to history, although one can be found in Roslindale.

The Hub of Literary America

You can learn more about Boston’s deep literary history on Boston By Foot’s “Hub of Literary America” tour. Given regularly during the tour season, it starts at the Old South Meeting House, which is located on, where else, Washington Street.

4 thoughts on “Washington Street Before George Washington

  1. Just come across this.
    In Dartmouth Devon England there is a Bayard’s Castle cheek by jowl with the Quay that was used by Mayflower in 1620 en route Plymouth Devon.
    Hope this might help

  2. Hi Aline … by chance I found your blog … I am trying find about the derivation of a street name in Allston MA … Bayard Street. I was reading a history text & learned that James A Bayard ( 1767-1815) served as Congressman from State of Delaware and later as US Senator/State of Delaware … and in the early period of American history, he was a staunch supporter of States’ rights. I am wondering if Bayard Street in Allston was named after this man. Can you help in verifying who Bayard St was named after … thanks. BTW- I do not use Facebook or Instagram, so if you have any info please send to my email … but I will check your blog. many thanks!!

    • Eileen: I looked through my books on Boston and did some research online but couldn’t find any information on Bayard Street in Allston,MA. It doesn’t seem like a street in Massachusetts would be named after a Delaware Senator, but the world was a smaller place then and families intermarried. If you find any other relevant information, please let me know.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *