3 Reasons Americans Speak Only English

Something that Susanne Skinner said in yesterday’s post, “Where Are You From?” has stayed with me. “A surprising number of people do not have a sense of the size and cultural diversity of the United Sates. Some have a very narrow or specific view of us.”

Snickering at Americans

Speak AmericanI have also found this to be true. This misunderstanding—among Europeans in particular—sometimes causes them to snicker at Americans because we typically speak only one language—English—and stumble our way through just pronouncing words in other languages. They think this must be because we’re arrogant, snobbish, elitist, and too lazy to learn the languages of other countries. They assume that we insist the rest of the world speak English just like the British empire once did.

Actually, it’s not that at all. There are three simple reasons why most Americans speak only English, all of which derive from one simple fact.

Geography is Destiny

Europeans live in countries that are small compared to the United States and they don’t grasp the fact that many of our states are as large as or larger than whole European countries. Why is this important?

Well, the easiest way to learn a language and to remain fluent in it is to hear it spoken and to speak it oneself on a regular basis. Europeans can grab their Eurail Pass and travel to other countries quickly, easily, and cheaply. In an hour, maybe less, they can hear and practice speaking a foreign language.

In the United States, this easy access is wishful thinking. Here are the three reasons why:

  1. America is huge. I can drive for an hour and still be in one relatively small state. It takes nearly four hours to drive just from Boston to New York City. A New Yorker can drive for an hour from Brooklyn to the Bronx and still be inside the city limits. It takes days to drive from one coast to another and six hours to fly across country.

map of Texas superimposed on map of Europe

Through the Eyes of Others

There’s a fascinating Quora feed on “What facts about the United States do foreigners not believe until they come to America?” This interesting look at us through the eyes of foreign visitors includes the following answers regarding the country’s size and distance:

  • “(1) The sheer size. Tried to explain to a friend that my state takes 6 hours to drive across at 120 kmh and that it’s not even the biggest state. A few told me driving through the plains area made them a bit agoraphobic. (2) That there are places in the US where you can be the only person in a 50-mile radius (not counting Alaska).” – Kenny Larson 
  • “I wasn’t from Chicago, New York, or Hollywood. Or Sacramento. That’s all there is in America, according to movies/I-don’t-know-what. They also assumed that you could run into ultra famous people, like, in the open market or on the bus; that you wouldn’t was unimaginable. The real problem was a lack of understanding about the enormity of the country itself, and the vast numbers of people here. America. It’s big.” — Joel Emmett 
  • “Distances. For example, how long it takes to drive from San Francisco to Los Angeles. Friends and relatives from Belgium and Italy have refused to believe me when I tell them they can’t drive down and back in an afternoon. It’s the opposite of what I found when I first visited Europe; I thought Amsterdam to Copenhagen would take several days to drive when, today, it actually takes much less.” – Ted Cuzillo 
  • “Foreigners cannot believe how vast the United States is. I am from the West Coast of the U.S. and my Italian relatives come here thinking they can visit me in Seattle, plus also see New York City, Miami, the Grand Canyon and Hollywood all in a week–by car. I can’t get them to understand that it’s 3,000 miles from the Pacific to the Atlantic coasts. They are amazed when I tell them that it takes five hours to drive east from my home in Seattle to my mom’s house in Spokane–and she lives in the same state. Washington, only the 16th largest of 50 states. – Candace Dempsey 

Proximity is Destiny

2. We share borders with only two countries. Our longest border (5,552 miles) is with Canada to the north and, thanks to the British Commonwealth, most people there speak English, too. Only in northeastern New England can an American drive across a border and speak a foreign language among the Francophone population of Quebec Province. (Parisians will argue that this language is not really French at all, but that’s their concern.) Mexico, to the south, does speak Spanish and Americans who live in states near that border (1,933 miles) have a much greater bilingual population. But that’s it. The rest is coastline bordered by the Atlantic and Pacific oceans and the Gulf of Mexico. The fish don’t talk.

Travel is Expensive

Eurail Pass3. Traveling to a foreign country is expensive. There is, unfortunately, no American version of a Eurail pass or Channel Tunnel that will take us to other countries. Neither can we step into a transporter or walk through a magic wardrobe. To get anywhere but Canada and Mexico, one must fly—and air fares are much more expensive than travel by road or rail. That means going to a foreign country is a once-in-a-lifetime trip for a great many Americans—and an impossible dream for many others.

But aren’t all Americans rich?  That’s another misconception thanks to Hollywood but, again, it’s not true. Most Americans are hard-working middle-class people who don’t have large amounts of disposable income to throw around. This is even more true following the Great Recession. If they do have travel money to spend, they tend to invest in something like a boat, a camper, or a recreational vehicle that they they can use frequently for the whole family. If people get to Europe or Asia at all, it’s for a couple of weeks only.

One doesn’t typically learn a foreign language just to use for two weeks out of an entire lifetime. Most people only need to speak English.

In a Nutshell

So that’s why most Americans speak only English. If you don’t believe me, come on over and drive from Maine to Miami. You will have access to French in the north and find people speaking Spanish in the south but, for everyone else in the middle, it’s all English all the time.

5 thoughts on “3 Reasons Americans Speak Only English

  1. I’d like to add a belated point of view to this post:

    1) Our various States used to be as different as european countries.

    2) The Civil War achieved in America what Napoleon and Hitler failed to achieve in Europe: monocultural conquest.

    3) The primary reason for the civil war is usually over slavery, but this is propagandism. The civil war was a fight between the northern industrial civilization and the souther agrarian civilization, over the proceeds of the Louisiana purchase: the western territories. Had the secession succeeded, the southern new western agrarian territories would have aligned with the Southern states and preserved slavery.

    4) American political conflict is just as much between the “Nine Nations” of north america, as it is between urban and rural, and minority races and whites.

    5) My suspicion is that we will have a break-up of the united states in the next half century which will coincide with the recognition of the failure of the european union project.

    • I know this is the Southern perspective, Curt. But the southern agrarian civilization could not have continued without slavery, which was the foundation of its prosperity. Thus you cannot separate the causes of the Civil War from slavery. It is a puzzle to me that the people of this region who pride themselves on their patriotism also celebrate the efforts of their ancestors to destroy the union. And who would do it again if they could. If we do have a breakup of the United States, it will be the South that suffers because those states currently receive more federal aid than they pay out in taxes. We here in the North would do OK as we would no longer have to subsidize the South. Just sayin’.

  2. I live in the US and find it hard to believe that you they couldn’t drive from San Francisco to Los Angeles and back in one afternoon, I’ve gone from state to state and back in less than a day, and those were not the smaller states. And the hour from Bronx to Brooklyn is bull, I drove from NJ through Bronx and Brooklyn and it didn’t even take 30 minutes

    • It all depends on the the traffic, Andrew, and how fast you drive, of course. Going from Brooklyn to the Bronx on a Sunday morning would take much less time than doing the same trip on a Friday night — which is when we were usually traveling. We we drove from LA to SF, we were not aiming for speed. We got off the freeway onto the PCH and stopped at the Hearst estate. I have also driven from Evanston IL to just outside of Washington DC in a long day. The U.S. is still a big country and much larger than Europe. England and Scotland are just a little bigger than New England and it’s about two hours from London to Yorkshire.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.